![]() |
Administrators :Dr Trout | |
| Forum Dr Trout\'s Outdoorworld |
Not logged | Login
|
|
| Online:1 guest is browsing the forum | ||
Register |
Profile |
Private messages |
Search |
Online | Help
| Create a free blog | ||
![]() | ||
|
| ![]() | ![]() |
| Author : | Topic: PGC January Meeting --- | Bottom |
| Dr Trout admin Posts : 1359 ![]() |
HERE ARE SOME ARTICLES ---- http://www.mcall.com/news/local/all-a1_5shotgun.6246815jan28,0,3728680.story http://local.lancasteronline.com/4/215747 --Last edited by Dr Trout on 2008-01-28 22:29:57 -- | |||
![]() |
| Dr Trout admin Posts : 1359 ![]() |
Here's Bluetick's summary of the meeting-- First thing - if anyone can correct or fill in any blanks or misunderstanding on my part please do so. Tough at times to hear what is going on and write at the same time. I make a good effort to get the "gist" of the testimony. This to convey the general thoughts of the person testifing. I do try to use their words - although most is shortened up. Meeting started on time with a full auditorium and lobby area. Several were standing. Pretty much a packed house. BOC President Boop stated that there was 62 people signed up to speak. A large portion of them were people attending the meeting in opposition to the proposed rule making concerning the Conure-Nanday. Basically a type of parrot. The long and short of all testimony on this was the bird is no threat. It could not survive the weather in PA. They would also quickly become hawk food as well. opponents also provided proof that there were no health issues with the birds. I will skip over the folks testifying to this issue. #1 Major theme was harvest reporting and deer management. * wanted a system similar to New York state. Phone and internet system with an emphasis on honesty in the system. * Deer management - Thought the GC could do better if not by WMU's. The gentleman couldn't understand the management goals. Ultimately wanted to return to the county management system. #2 Father of three boys - Anniheim PA (hunts Bedford County) * Few deer seen. *Kids losing interest in hunting deer. * He does support habitat improvement through deer program - *Make driving deer on public land illegally. * Make doe tag legal on private land only. #3 Ken Kane Consulting Foresters, Kane, PA * maintain deer program as is. * No need to modify concurrent season. *The organization will work for a license increase. *Keep current season and bag limits to maintain consistency of data. #4 Unknown *stop doe hunting *will not purchase hunting license next year * poaching is as big a problem as the doe harvests #5 Governors Youth Advisory Council They as a group decided and testified that: * they support a license increase for the GC They would like this to restore the many programs canceled or suspended due to funding issues. Such as Women in the Outdoors Program, pheasant stocking (restore to full program), and the donation of Game News to school libraries. * They thanked the GC BOC for the Mentored Hunter Program. * They asked for an expanded mentored youth hunting opportunities to include fall turkey and waterfowl * Yes to Sunday hunting #6 Unk *Wants the GC to provide more recreational activity * He proposed a four week crossbow season to start two weeks after the fall archery season * extend the early muzzleloader season to a full two weeks #7 Todd Spark Hancock forest Management * Manages 116,000 acres in the NC region * Supports scientific management of the deer herd *keep the two week concurrent season as is and DMAP * They think reducing the concurrent season will make the harvest hard to manage * increase doe harvest in all of 2g - or if better to target the areas needing more thinning realign the boundary to a north and south unit (sub-unit) and target the southern portion * DMAP should be available for lease holders and all property owners #8 Dan Devline Director DCNR Forestry * Congratulated the GC on it's science based management * He stated he understood the challenges of satisfying a large stakeholder group(hunters) * Stated that people need to understand the forest and deer and deer management are linked * Without hunter the forest health would suffer * He agreed with the GC that the best indicator of forest health is regen monitoring * Many parts of the state forest system are improving * many areas of the state forest show reduced browsing pressure * Some biologists and others are seeing plants growing they have never seen before * DMAP is a great tool * The Forestry Department of DCNR is taking a hard look at DMAP areas - adding and deleting as required * still - many areas showing little or no regen - mostly in the northern areas * stated the oak component of the state forest is reduced (bad for wildlife) *maple, black birch are replacing oaks and can not support wildlife * the decisions we make today will affect the next generation (hunters / people) * DCNR Forestry opposed WMU changes Reasons - reduced opportunity to hunt and harvest - limits or changes the data for future decisions - large portions of some remote areas are still under hunted ////// This testimony is usually posted on the DCNR site. I will try to post it when it becomes available/// #9 UNK from NWTF * Seeks continued shortened fall turkey season in 2F * called attention to the lack of turkey information in the annual report published in the January Game News * Wants article detailing turkey study and other involvement of the NWTF published in Game News #10 Sampson - Forest land Group * Expand mentored youth hunting * Expand small game hunting though the fall uninterrupted * add antlerless deer for mentored youth * supports license increase * Does not support the first week buck second week concurrent proposed season calling it deer for dollars *Deer for dollars will result in lessened opportunities in those four WMU's #11 ? * wants the GC to be creative * wants habitat stamp * no deer - there is little quality public hunting ground * Graded the GC on many issues. Overall the GC got a failing grade... * supports and demands the addition of prescribed burning to forestry practices #12 Paul miller Department of AG - representing self - /// couldn't hear - people talking// #13 Blake Fuller - Collins Timber * seeing improvement of regen due to less browsing * recovery of the forest takes time * wants the GC to use science not emotion and politics to make decisions * opposes the split buck/concurrent season. Asked the GC to review their new deer management book - asked what changed... * wants large landowners to be able to issue DMAP tags directly *expand mentored youth hunting #13 ? Penn State Ag/Forest Committee (?? noisy best I could do) * strongly support concurrent season * strong support for Sunday hunting * DMAP is a success story - make it available for all land owners * WMU's are to big * Make no changes to the two week concurrent season * yes to license increase. #14 Phil Wagner - Union County 4D * Giving up on deer management - no change is coming * reiterated his soil test testimony from a year ago * deer conditions are bad in Union County * wants to know if the GC is checking the DCNR DMAP data they use for tags #15 Steve Mohr - President USP - former GC Commissioner * handed in petition on deer management * Made a statement about the birders being here instead of hunters * Compared deer season being canceled at the last minute to the Super Bowl being canceled at the last minute * stated he was not here as the enemy * claimed deer are being controlled by deep pockets and special interest #16 * missed name noise and people moving governor's Advisory Council * support license increase * support Sunday hunting * expand mentored Youth hunting * vacancies in the GC at about 109 * please publish wildlife management plans #17 Ryan Becker Susquehanna Beagle Clubs * add rabbit hunting (over dogs0 to the mentored hunt * Vermont allows this for mentored youth 8 Explained how it works using the rules in place. Very interesting presentation. #18 ? * has hunted for 30 years * in conjunction with QMDA planted 1600 trees and food plots * volunteers are an untapped resources that should be taken advantage of by the GC * want a reg for no-driving on SGL's * doe tags for private land only # 19 Casey * bear issues in 3D * end extended bear season in 3D #20 Mr. White * got rid of 23 doe tags in four years * Gives up - no license purchase / tag * blames the timber and insurance companies * QDM = Quick Deer Massacre * to few deer to hunt #21 ? * wants a regulation added to exceptions in title 34 (article cited) to allow pistols up to .45 cal in 5C #22 Robert ? * GC and GC BOC brainwashed into thinking deer are a problem *There are no deer problems in West Virginia and New York * DCNR is doing a wonderful job of brainwashing #23 PA Forest product Association * Opposed to four WMU split season * split season not based on science * split season will not support program goals * the four WMU's equate to 20% of all WMU acreage * Damages data collection * Weather will have more impact on harvests #24 ? * there are no deer in north Potter Co - public or private land * I know of eight camps - only 13 deer killed * no luck in three years hunted all season * son stated he didn't want to go back * finally teamed up with other camps to do small drives * started killing deer * Put out trail cams and never would have believed the deer numbers (went on in some detail on numbers of deer) * Opposes the changes to the four WMU's - a step backwards * hopes the proposed change isn't politically motivated * Hope the proposed change is not to appease politicians - if so we lose. #25 Tioga Co Farmer * was told there were 800 bear in Tioga Co * wants a change in depredation permits to add bear * has a lot of damage on his farm * lets people hunt on his property * opposes any changes to deer season in 3A * stay the course on deer #26 John Pries NWTF * please vote to repeal the use of FO in spring turkey season * add fall turkey to Mentored Youth hunting * make the youth hunt for spring turkey all day or add a few days (time and weather issues) * proposed a study on all day spring turkey hunting for four years. Re-evaluate then #27 Steve Trupe PA QDM GalThatFishes will post testimony for him - #28 Western Pennsylvania Conservancy /// this is not their exact testimony - but the overall content is the same// http://www.paconserve.org/pressroom/pdfs/Eradication%20and%20Prevention%20of%20Feral%20Swine.pdf #29 ? * wants driving deer eliminated * had several negative stories to back his position #30 ? * used the theme of sportsmanship in regard to improper atv use * atv's trespassing on SGL's * legislature doing little to help * magistrates letting people off and giving the lest fine * wants Title 75 enforced by all law enforcement #31 Keystone Trail Association * GC is revising the trail policy * they seek to continue their work in conjunction with the GC #32 ? 3C * hunts on public land * proud of what the GC has done on deer management * happy to see the four WMU split season proposal * thinks things can be change to improve deer numbers though * look close at tag numbers and adjust the doe tags up to account for fewer days #33 Charles ? * close doe season in 2G for several years # 34 A Forester // Missed most of his testimony// * listen to your staff biologists #35 ? Mifflintown * walked seven miles and only cut three tracks * put deer back on SGL's * small game is down as well #36 Rep Levdansky * update on the Legislative Finance and Budget Committee plan for the deer audit * RFP (request for proposal) might be sent to specific companies before the end of the month * thinks this does need done by a company outside the state * time to put the anger and fighting over deer away - time to move forward * outlined some of the parameters they are asking to be looked at * promised to work on getting the GC funded through a license increase as well as his general funding bill Day Two #37 Henry Carcat (sp - sorry) PFB * 5C shotgun only proposal does not agree with the LFBC study - BOC needs to re-look this issue * Supports the early and extended deer seasons * the proposed change to four WMU's contain 13,584 farms and 2 million acres - changes are not based on science. Deer are the number one source of damage to crops after weather. * passing the changes will hurt farmers /// BOC member asked how many farms used DMAP in 5C - answer pending) #38 Ken Bectel (sp) PFB Wildlife Damage Committee * His personal farm damage (crops) is being increased by surrounding posted property * wants the rules concerning having others do animal control / crop damaged relaxed remove DMAP and Red Tag restrictions and allow all that is allowed under HB 881 (passed) * Ferrel hogs/pigs/boars - the BOC needs to go with limited hunting let the USDA trap them * Ferrel hogs/pigs/boars - they need eliminated totally #39 Audubon PA * wants science based deer program *Ferrell hogs/pigs need eliminated from PA * remove requirement for tagging one deer before killing another * opposes the four WMU split season proposal * hogs pigs in five counties - they need eradicated * they oppose hunting in favor of trapping so they do not further disperse. #40 GalThatFishes She will post her final testimony #41 Tom Mckinney Stoney Valley #42 Greg Shank ? * whats the need for the four WMU change * better to change harvest by using tag allocations * if approved - switch the weeks - concurrent first - buck second week * Has issues on the results of FLIR results - not accurate. In his area the deer gravitate to the feeders making the results inaccurate. * suggested "flipping" around pheasant stocking. For every pheasant stocked release three quail. They are cheaper and more reuseable ... for the average hunter. # 42 Ed Wentzler UBP * supports 5C boundry realignment * Make exception for .22 caliber rifles for predators and chucks * expand Mentored hunting to include does in the early season # 43 John Pries - as individual * ferrel hogs need eliminated * not allowing unlimited hunting allows them to go unchecked 2/3 of the year * not hunting them allows the numbers to increase twice a year * by not recognizing them as invasive you in essence protect them * hogs need unlimited killing throughout the year #44 Representative Robert Godshall ' hunted hogs in California and Texas. They seem to get along good with deer. Something to hunt when there are no deer'. * recounted his travel to camp this year and stopping in a restruant. Usually filled with hunters, few there. * ' I have no idea what scientific deer management the GC is using' * scientific deer management... ' they need to talk to hunters... they are hurting good people... needs to have more in it than tree's and browsing'. * saw few or no deer at camp * In Reference to Rep Levdansky - * 'the study will probabley be done, they need to bring in DCNR and DEP ( into to it??), it (study) needs to tell us the number of deer" #45 Paul Shup - Save Stoney Creek _________________________ Hunting - more than just buying a license. Get involved! --Last edited by Dr Trout on 2008-01-28 23:17:27 -- | |||
![]() |
| dpms moderator Posts : 445 ![]() |
Today (Tuesday) should be the fireworks. Let's here them if ya got them... |
| dpms moderator Posts : 445 ![]() |
Sort of bummed out that the PGC caved on the doe season length issue after only 6 years. Let's hope that this study area of 4 units provides the data they need in one year or two max. They outcome will be interesting to say the least. The PGC will either have egg on its face and the anti-pgc crowd will be singing and dancing or if the data shows that allocations effect harvest and not season length, the entire state back to weeks concurrent. If they have the balls to do it. which I am not sure about these days. Also, when allocations are announced, I will be highly disappointed if the allocations in those units are reduced. They should not be if there is any weight to the study. |
| dpms moderator Posts : 445 ![]() |
They did table a proposal to have all counties within the SRA go to shotgun and rimfire only. From what I heard only 2 people spoke out against this proposed change stating studies showing shotguns no more safer than rifles and 1 person citing the added expense of buying new guns to keep hunting in the same areas as in the past. |
| bowbum Posts : 64 ![]() |
dpms, the "study" is now 4 years instead of 3 years. I've already seen comment about; "the other 18 units won't be affected until 4 years down the road." Sounds like some think it is a done deal! There was very significant opposition to this from informed and educated people in the industry and sciences, but it still passed --- what does that tell you? I think the hullabaloo about deer numbers is our own diversion from the most important factor: We can make all sorts of excuses but there is absolutely no doubt that this is a stumbling block to family participation. No doubt whatsoever! Requiring two seperate seasons for the licenses/permits for adults directly affects decisions and forces hard choices. That simply is going backwards from a workable and opportuned situation that took 100 years to achieve! |
| dpms moderator Posts : 445 ![]() |
I agree with you Bowbum. How about the pressure on the button bucks that first saturday?? Something the PGC was trying to reduce with a 2 week season. |
| rich Posts : 177 ![]() |
Unless I am missing something, isn't this a way for the PGC to micromanage within The WMUs and see the real effects of changing seasons and limits instead of speculating what might happen? |
| dpms moderator Posts : 445 ![]() |
It is a way of micromanaging but we had three day seasons for how long? Then we had 2 week seasons for 6 years. A statistician should be able to figure out allocations, season length and harvest relationships based on that data. This is nothing more than a compromise for other gains. |
| rich Posts : 177 ![]() |
Nothing like hard cold facts when you are doing a study. Besides they get blamed for overworking the statisticians already when they figure out the deer kill for the year. dd |
|
| ![]() | ![]() |
Get a free forum!
AceBoard Free Forum v 5.3
Download Premium Web Templates!